Right now, The Black Donnellys is on Peacock Premium and several other platforms, sitting at 8/10 on TMDB. Consistently well-regarded, and easy to understand why once you start watching.

At its heart, The Black Donnellys is a procedural that understands what makes the genre work — character first, plot second. Meet the Donnelly brothers: Tommy, Jimmy, Kevin and Sean. There is nothing these four Irish brothers wouldn't do to protect each other, and for them that means lying, cheating, stealing and, occasionally, calling the cops. Narrated by wannabe gangster Joey "Ice Cream," this gritty series bears witness to the Donnelly brothers' sudden involvement in organized crime, focusing on how they go from boys to mobsters, and showing how their new life affects their relationships with friends, family and lovers. Jonathan Tucker and Tom Guiry lead a cast that brings real weight to the material. It aired in 2007.

Perfect for viewers who think they've already seen all the great crime dramas. The Black Donnellys is the one that tends to prove them wrong.