What Would You Do?

Skip the manufactured drama elsewhere — What Would You Do?, in the US on Disney Plus and Hulu, understands its own format. 17 seasons is a serious commitment, but one that pays off episode after episode. With 12 viewer ratings on TMDB, this is not a title flying under the radar. John Quiñones is a big part of why it works, but the format itself is the real star. Put it on tonight on Disney Plus and see for yourself.

Part of the current wave of titles people are actually watching, What Would You Do? Earns its spot. What separates What Would You Do? From the rest of its genre is a genuine understanding of what its audience actually wants to watch. An American television news magazine and hidden camera show. Actors act out scenes of conflict or illegal activity in public settings while hidden cameras videotape the scene, and the focus is on whether or not bystanders intervene, and how. Variations are also usually included, such as changing the genders, the races or the clothing of the actors performing the scene, to see if bystanders react differently. Watching John Quiñones and Sara Haines navigate it is most of the appeal. It ran for 17 seasons (2008–2024), and the writing holds up across every one of them. The editing in What Would You Do? Does a lot of quiet work shaping how you feel about every person on screen. It rarely drops the ball, and when it does, it recovers fast.

Reality sceptics are warned — What Would You Do? Has converted more than a few doubters. The Real Housewives of Beverly Hills is the obvious comparison, but What Would You Do? Earns its own place alongside it. At 17 seasons, this is a genuine commitment — one that pays off. The production understands its own premise and executes on it without apology. If you have enjoyed similar formats before, this is one of the stronger examples of what the genre can do.

What Would You Do? is currently airing new episodes — so there's no better time to catch up before the story moves forward. Find exactly where it's streaming below, and TV Butler Pro makes it effortless to track your progress as you go. Just search the name, and Butler finds it instantly, tells you which service has it, and remembers exactly where you left off.